Example 1: Bad Result, student CB.

Diagram
Parts
All *
Some
None
Labels
All
Some
None
Readability
Good
Poor
Bad
Observation
Number
>3
=3
<3 *
Depth
Tried something with result
Result only, but not what they did
What they see only *
Question
Number
>3
=3
<3 *
Depth
Shows Connection to concept(s)
Shows more depth than covered
Basic concept questions *
external image clip_image002.jpgmackerman_cb.jpg

Example 2: Poor Result, student JF.

Diagram
Parts
All
Some *
None
Labels
All
Some *
None
Readability
Good *
Poor
Bad
Observation
Number
>3 *
=3
<3
Depth
Tried something with result
Result only, but not what they did *
What they see only
Question
Number
>3 *
=3
<3
Depth
Shows Connection to concept(s)
Shows more depth than covered *
Basic concept questions
mackerman_jf.jpg
external image clip_image004.jpg

Example 3: Good Result, student JM.

Diagram
Parts
All *
Some
None
Labels
All *
Some
None
Readability
Good *
Poor
Bad
Observation
Number
>3 *
=3
<3
Depth
Tried something with result *
Result only, but not what they did
What they see only
Question
Number
>3
=3 *
<3
Depth
Shows Connection to concept(s) *
Shows more depth than covered
Basic concept questions
external image clip_image006.jpgmackerman_jm.jpg